Restaurant Calculator

Tip Pooling & Sharing: The Complete Guide for Restaurant Owners

Sahana Ananth
July 19, 2024
1 mins

Table of Content

Let's start with a shocker: even with tips, waiters and bartenders often earn a shockingly low hourly wage. Studies show tips make up a significant portion of their income (52% - 54%), with many relying on them for basic necessities. 

As restaurant owners, without tipping restaurants would face a balancing act. You might have to raise menu prices to compensate staff, implement a service charge, or switch to a salary-based system. 

This could lead to sticker shock for customers AND a less personalized experience. Leading to what? Low performing staff. Hence, tipping becomes crucial for restaurant staff because it supplements lower wages, rewards good service directly from happy customers, encourages teamwork within the staff, and provides additional income for career advancement, all contributing to a more motivated and successful restaurant experience for everyone.

Now how can you, as a restaurant owner, make sure tipping is fair and keeps your staff motivated? Continue reading this blog to know all about managing tips at your restaurant.

Understanding Tip Pooling

Welcome to the world of tip pooling, where teamwork becomes the name of the game, and everyone benefits from a happy, well-oiled restaurant ops machine. But before you dive headfirst into the pool, let's break down the essentials and help you create a system that keeps your staff motivated and your customers coming back for more.

Tip Pooling Calculator

Download our Tip Pooling Calculator to accurately divide tips based on hours worked for both front and back-of-house staff in seconds.

What is Tip Pooling?

Imagine a pot of gold, filled with all the tips your amazing staff collects. Now, picture everyone on the team dipping in and sharing the wealth fairly. That's essentially tip pooling! It's a way to combine all the tips earned in a shift and distribute them among eligible employees based on a predetermined method. This ensures everyone benefits from good service, not just the servers who snag the best tables.

Note: Tip pooling is NOT tip sharing. Tip sharing is voluntary. A server might choose to share some of their own tips with colleagues as a gesture of appreciation. Tip pooling is a mandatory system.

Legalities To Consider When Implementing Tip Pooling

The legality of tip pooling for restaurants in the USA depends on federal and potentially state regulations. Here's a breakdown:

Federal Level:

  1. Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA): This federal law allows employers to implement mandatory tip pooling, with some key restrictions:
  2. Eligible Employees: Only employees who customarily and regularly receive tips can be included in the pool. This typically means front-of-house staff like servers, bartenders, bussers, and food runners.
  3. Managers and Supervisors: They are strictly prohibited from participating in the tip pool or receiving tips directly from the pool.
  4. Tip Credit: Example, California prohibits tip credits. This means employers cannot take a portion of the minimum wage based on tips received by employees. They must be paid the full minimum wage before tips. Check your state's regulations to see if tip credits are allowed and how they might affect tip pooling.
  5. Fair and Reasonable Distribution: The tip pool distribution method must be fair and reasonable. Common methods include sales-based, hours worked, or a combination of both.

State Level:

Some states might have additional regulations specific to tip pooling. It's crucial to consult your state's Department of Labor website or an employment attorney to ensure your tip pool policy complies with all applicable laws.

Here are some resources to help you learn more:

  1. U.S. Department of Labor (DOL): Provides detailed information on tip laws in the USA, including tip pooling guidelines, check here.
  2. Your State's Department of Labor website: Look for information on specific regulations related to tip pooling in your state.

By understanding both federal and potentially state-specific regulations, you can implement a legal and fair tip pooling system for your restaurant.

Common Tip Pool Distribution Methods Explained with Examples

Here's a breakdown of common tip pool distribution methods for your restaurant, along with illustrative examples for each to help you understand in depth. 

1. Sales-Based Distribution

Distribution method: Employees receive a share of the tip pool based on the total sales they generate. This incentivizes high sales volume and motivates employees to upsell or provide excellent service that leads to higher bills.

Example for Sales-based tip pooling:

Total Tip Pool: $1,000

Server A: Sales - $500

Server B: Sales - $300

Server C: Sales - $200

Tip Pooling Calculation:

Each server's contribution percentage = Individual Sales / Total Sales (e.g., Server A: 500 / 1000 = 0.5)

Tip Share = Total Tip Pool * Contribution Percentage (e.g., Server A: 1000 * 0.5 = $500)

Outcome = Server A, with the highest sales, receives the most tips ($500), while Server C receives the least ($200).

2. Hours Worked Distribution

Distribution method: Tips are divided based on the total hours worked by each employee in the pool. This is a simpler method to administer but might not reflect individual effort on high-volume days.

Example for hours-based tip pooling:

Total Tip Pool: $1,000

Server A: Hours Worked - 8

Server B: Hours Worked - 6

Server C: Hours Worked - 4

Tip Pooling Calculation:

Each server's contribution percentage = Individual Hours / Total Hours (e.g., Server A: 8 / 18 = 0.44)

Tip Share = Total Tip Pool * Contribution Percentage (e.g., Server A: 1000 * 0.44 = $440)

Outcome = Server A, who worked the longest shift, receives the most tips ($440), even though their sales might not have been the highest.

3. Combined Sales & Hours

Distribution method: This hybrid approach takes both sales and hours worked into account. It can be a good balance, rewarding high performers while recognizing effort put in during slower times.

Example for Sales and hours based tip pooling:

Total Tip Pool: $1,000

Weight Sales as 70% and Hours as 30%

Server A: Sales - $500 & Hours Worked - 8

Server B: Sales - $300 & Hours Worked - 6

Server C: Sales - $200 & Hours Worked - 4

Calculation for Combined Sales & Hours: 

Sales weightage = (Individual Sales / Total Sales) * 0.7 (e.g., Server A: (500 / 1000) * 0.7 = 0.35)

Hours weightage = (Individual Hours / Total Hours) * 0.3 (e.g., Server A: (8 / 18) * 0.3 = 0.13)

Combine weightages = Sales weightage + Hours weightage (e.g., Server A: 0.35 + 0.13 = 0.48)

Tip Share = Total Tip Pool * Combined Weightage (e.g., Server A: 1000 * 0.48 = $480)

Outcome = Server A receives the most tips ($480) due to higher sales and longer hours, while Server B and C receive proportionally less based on their contributions.

Tip Pooling Calculator

Accurately calculate and distribute tips with ease using our FREE Tip Pooling Calculator template. Download now!

4. Modified Factors

Distribution method: Some restaurants incorporate additional factors beyond sales or hours. This could include guest satisfaction surveys, number of tables served, or resolving customer complaints.

Example:

  1. Base distribution can be done using Sales or Hours worked.
  2. Points are assigned for exceeding a certain guest satisfaction rating or resolving a specific number of complaints.
  3. These points are then added to the base contribution percentage for the final tip share calculation.

How to Calculate the Tip Pooling for Restaurants

Think of the tip pool as a delicious pie. First, you need all the ingredients:

Total Tips Collected: This is the sum of all the tips your restaurant receives during a specific period (a shift, a day, or a week).

Next, you need to decide how to slice the pie:

Distribution Method: This is where things get interesting! We'll explore different methods in a bit. Each method assigns a "slice size" to each employee based on factors like sales generated or hours worked.

Finally, you divvy up the pie!

Individual Tip Share: Once you have the total tip pool and the distribution method, you can calculate each employee's share.

How to Choose the Right Tip Pool Method?

Now that you know how to bake different pie flavors, which one is best for your restaurant?  Well, it depends on your unique recipe!

  • Restaurant Size and Service Style: Is it a fast-paced pizzeria or a high-end steakhouse?
  • Staff Dynamics: Do you have a team-oriented environment or more individual focus?
  • Desired Outcomes: Are you aiming for fairness, motivation, or a balance of both?

For a small pizzeria, a sales-based or combined method might incentivize teamwork and upselling. Whereas a high-volume sports bar requires a combined method with a stronger emphasis on hours worked to be fair for busy evenings with many servers.

3 Things to Remember When Implementing Tip Pool Method for Your Restaurant

Once you choose your method, ensure its success with these tips:

  1. Communicate Clearly: Explain the method and calculation process to your staff in detail.
  2. Record Keeping: Keep accurate records of tips, sales and hours for transparency.
  3. Regular Review: See how things are going and adjust the method if needed.

Restaurant Tip Pooling Q&A

Is Tip Pooling Legal?

Yes, tip pooling is legal under federal law (FLSA) with some key restrictions. However, some states might have additional regulations. Always check your state's Department of Labor website to ensure compliance.

Is Tip Pooling a Good Idea for Small Restaurants?

Tip pooling can be beneficial for restaurants of all sizes. It can foster teamwork, ensure everyone benefits from good service, and simplify tip distribution.

What Are the Standard Restaurant Tip Percentages by Role?

There are no standard percentages by law. However, 15-20% is a common tipping range for good service in the USA. Tip pooling eliminates the need for individual tip calculations.

Can Managers Join in Tip Pooling?

No, managers and supervisors cannot participate in the tip pool.

What Distinguishes Tip Pooling from Tip Sharing?

Tip sharing is voluntary. An employee might choose to share some of their own tips with colleagues. Tip pooling is a mandatory system where all tips are collected and then distributed among eligible employees based on a predetermined method.

What Are the Consequences of Non-Compliance with Tip Pooling Rules?

Non-compliance can lead to fines and penalties from the Department of Labor, wage-and-hour lawsuits from employees, and employee morale issues.

What Are the Potential Downsides of Tip Pooling?
  • Some high performers might feel discouraged if their share is similar to lower-performing colleagues.
  • It requires clear communication and record-keeping to avoid confusion or resentment.
What Is a Tip Credit?

In some states with allowed tip credits, employers can take a portion of the minimum wage based on tips received by employees. This essentially allows employers to pay tipped employees a lower base wage.

How Are Tips Handled at the End of a Business Day?

Tips are typically collected throughout the day and pooled at the end of the shift. The pool is then distributed among eligible employees based on the chosen method.

Can Back-of-House Staff Be Included in Tip Pools?

Federal law allows including only employees who customarily and regularly receive tips.  This typically excludes back-of-house staff like cooks and dishwashers. However, some states might have different regulations.

AUTHOR
Sahana Ananth
Director, GTM - OneHubPOS

Sahana is a seasoned GTM leader with a passion for building startups. She excels in crafting GTM strategies for tech products, driving revenue growth.

Read more